|
We guarantee your privacy: 1. We will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever. 2. We will never send you any unrequested e-mail, besides newsletter updates. 3. All unsubscribe requests are honored immediately, period. Privacy policy |
|
TOP STORY — info you need to make Windows work Antispyware apps vie for top spot By Brian Livingston Things are moving so quickly in the world of spyware that the major computer magazines should really retest all antispyware applications every three months or so. Fortunately, three new reviews have come out just in the past week to give us fresh results. Nothing should surprise me any more, but this did: The three reviewers each picked a different antispyware app to receive the magazine's top score. InfoWorld Magazine lauded an integrated package from F-Secure, while ranking the well-known Sunbelt CounterSpy Enterprise only fourth out of 10 contenders. Network Computing, by contrast, found CounterSpy the best, rating the F-Secure product only fifth out of seven products. Meanwhile, PC Magazine gave the most points to, of all things, Microsoft AntiSpyware Beta. Does this mean all three reviewers are wrong? Or are all three right? F-Secure heads InfoWorld list InfoWorld tested 10 corporate antispyware packages, which are designed to protect as few as five workstations up to thousands. These business-oriented versions, which cost about $20 to $30 per year in quantities of 100 seats, are not designed for home use. But good ratings for an enterprise-level product suggest that the same company's single-user version might also be strong. In the weekly magazine's Sept. 19 issue, reviewer Keith Schultz gave the top score to F-Secure Anti-Virus Client Security 6. "It has the best real-time protection of any products in this roundup, stopping all attempts," he says. The bundle combines antivirus, antispyware, and personal firewall protection. InfoWorld's ratings for F-Secure and the other contenders are: • F-Secure Anti-Virus Client Security 6 (Score: 9.3/10.0) • Webroot Spy Sweeper Enterprise 2.5 (8.8) • LANDesk Secuity Suite 8.6 (8.7) • Sunbelt CounterSpy Enterprise 1.5 (8.5) • SurfControl Enterprise Protection Suite (8.3) • McAfee VirusScan Ent. 8.0 w/Anti-Spyware (8.2) • Trend Micro Anti-Spyware for SMB 3.0 (8.1) • CA eTrust PestPatrol Anti-Spyware Corp. 5 (7.6) • Eset NOD32 2.5 Antivirus System (7.2) • Tenebril SpyCatcher 4.0 (beta, not rated) CounterSpy rules at Network Computing Only days later, CounterSpy Enterprise walked away with the Editor's Choice award from Network Computing, which, like InfoWorld, has an invitation-only circulation. CounterSpy's "spyware detection and prevention were excellent," says reviewer Christopher Beers, a systems operations manager for Time Warner Cable Broadband. "The number of unwanted running processes also was drastically reduced, more so than with the other products we tested." Network Computing's Sept. 22 issue gives the following scores to the seven packages tested: • Sunbelt CounterSpy Enterprise 1.5 (Score: 4.28/5.00). • Trend Micro Anti-Spyware for SMB 3.0 (4.15). • Webroot Spy Sweeper Enterprise 2.1 (3.85). • McAfee VirusScan Ent. 8.0 w/Anti-Spyware (3.78). • F-Secure Anti-Virus Client Security 6 (3.63). • Lavasoft Ad-Aware SE Enterprise (3.00). • CA eTrust PestPatrol Anti-Spyware Corp. 5 (2.70). According to the magazine, seven other companies declined to participate in the testing: Determina, Eset, Microsoft, Omniquad, Panda, SurfControl, and Tenebril. Free MS tool is cool with PC Mag Rather than testing antispyware software for networks, PC Magazine goes to the other end of the spectrum, reviewing in its Oct. 18 issue three single-user utilities that are free of charge. (This article does not yet appear to be posted at PCMag.com.) |
Windows Secrets Newsletter Issue 61 — 2005.09.29 TOP STORY • Antispyware apps vie for top spot • F-Secure heads InfoWorld list • CounterSpy rules at Network Computing • Free MS tool is cool with PC Mag • My advice: pay a little and get the best • ZoneAlarm copes with complexity SECURITY BASELINE • The Security Baseline as it now stands WINDOWS GIZMOS • Devices help you connect, click, and swap • More than your average Wi-Fi detector • Sony ships credit-card size T5 camera • Copy 8 kinds of memory without a PC INDEX OF REVIEWS • New digital cameras produce new reviews • Sony awarded T3's Best Buy • Synch names favorites in digicams • Canon ranked highest by Digital Photography • Four cameras get special recognition • New Casio takes over top spot • Plextor DVD wins PC Pro lab tests • Three-way tie among CNET's player picks HOT TIPS • Readers debate ZoneAlarm pros and cons • Clean install resolves e-mail problem • Can ZA really reduce a fixed-size swap file? • Software firewall conflicts with VPN • "Stop all Internet activity" stops intranet, too • Cable download speeds drop to 2400 Kbps • Privacy checking affects HTML of Web pages WOODY'S WINDOWS • Resurrect your deleted files and photos • Simple ways to screw up your pics • Where photos go when they die • How to get your pictures back • You always have other options OVER THE HORIZON • Symantec report errs on Firefox security • Firefox vs. IE, by the numbers • The evidence adds up against IE • Which flaws got fixed is crucial WINDOWS PATCH WATCH • What's a girl to do with no patches? • Patches get complicated for Exchange and SBS • Got BSOD? Get thee new drivers! • Firefox isn't perfect, but patches come fast • False positives affect Spybot and ActiveX • SP2 for Office 2003, SharePoint released • Hacked MS Access files can infect you • Beware of the latest Web scams WACKY WEB WEEK • OkCupid plays free Internet matchmaker USEFUL LINKS • Inkjet wars: cheap ink vs. expensive • Inkjet wars 2: preserving your prints NEWSLETTER CONTROL PANEL • Windows Secrets home page • How to subscribe • Change your delivery address • Change your preferences • Access past free issues • Access past paid issues • Upgrade to paid version • Search for info (WinFind) • Submit a Windows tip • Get subscription help • How to unsubscribe CIRCULATION: over 146,000 |
|
Microsoft's AntiSpyware program, currently in beta testing, got the highest score,
although that was merely 3.5 stars out of a possible 5.0. "We found it quite effective at
removing spyware, but less so at blocking initial installations," says lead analyst Neil
Rubenking. Microsoft's flawed spyware blocking was enough, though, to beat out the other tested products, Ad-Aware SE Personal and Spybot Search & Destroy. The free versions of those two products offer no real-time protection at all. PC Magazine's tepid ratings for the latter two utilities shows the sad decline of these products, which a year or two ago could slay almost any adware or spyware in circulation: • Microsoft Windows AntiSpyware (beta, Score: 3.5/5.0) • Lavasoft Ad-Aware SE Personal 1.06 (3.0) • Spybot Search & Destroy 1.4 (2.5) My advice: pay a little and get the best Although Microsoft AntiSpyware didn't get an Editors' Choice award, its top score in PC Magazine implies an endorsement. That's unfortunate. As I reported on July 14, Microsoft's malware detector no longer recommends that end users remove adware by Claria, 180Solutions, WhenU, and many others. The reason seems to be that these programs do display an OK button in a vague dialog box before they're installed. Clicking this button supposedly binds you to the adware's end-user license agreement. Microsoft wants above all for EULAs to be seen as legitimate, no matter what may be in them. Antispyware is so important that it's a category of software you shouldn't expect to get for free. The cost is a mere $20 per year for the personal version of CounterSpy, and its enterprise version runs as low as $11 per year for 1,000 seats (including first-year support). F-Secure's bundle costs only a little more: about $30 per year per 1,000. To prevent the theft of your banking passwords or your very identity, $1 or $2 a month is well worth paying. Because these products are complex, it's understandable that different, respected reviewers often come up with different results. For this reason, I read as many reviews as I can before reporting in the Security Baseline, which appears below, that any particular product is "top-rated." When serious reviewers differ, I list whichever product earns the largest number of positive results. In the case of antispyware utilities, the personal version of CounterSpy has been top-rated by both Laptop Magazine and PC World. In addition, the enterprise version has earned the top rating from three major magazines: eWeek, Windows IT Pro, and now Network Computing. For these reasons, CounterSpy remains the champ in the Security Baseline's antispyware category. If and when some other product wins more ratings, that product will take the throne. ZoneAlarm copes with complexity I reported last issue that Zone Labs had released an updated 6.0 version of its product line, including ZoneAlarm Pro and ZoneAlarm Security Suite. Version 6.0.667 (Sept. 6) was said by Zone Labs representatives to correct install problems with version 6.0.631 (July 21). This was confirmed by several ZoneAlarm users who frequent the company's online user forum. Since that time, I've received more than 100 e-mail messages about this, some from ZoneAlarm users who had no problems or easily corrected them, others from unhappy customers who are still experiencing show-stopper headaches. In a telephone interview, ZA product marketing manager Jordy Berson confirmed that 6.0's novel "operating system firewall" and its new antispyware capabilities could conflict with other security products. "Because we just released this brand new technology, we're seeing issues with vendors that we're working out," Berson says. Fortunately, most ZA users aren't bumping into these conflicts, he added, saying the number is similar to previous "point-oh" rollouts. The problems readers are running into seem to fall into four broad categories. Berson provided me with detailed responses to try to resolve ZA user's complaints: 1. ZoneAlarm allegedly reduces a 3GB Windows swap file to 2GB. Berson: "Our developers and QA [quality assurance] can't think of how we would affect the file in this way. Could it be another factor on these computers? If these users contact support, we would certainly be happy to continue investigating the cases, though." 2. Two readers say ZA cuts their cable download speeds almost in half. Berson: "While it's true we have some performance slow-downs, we’ve never seen anything of this magnitude. We have a performance testing lab dedicated to monitoring performance in all kinds of conditions. We do see consistent, slight drops in performance due to the extra processing the firewall does to monitor traffic and protect the computer. But it's very slight — and generally not noticeable by customers." 3. ZA repeatedly reboots one reader's PC when PrevX is also running. Berson: "The OS firewall goes where other firewalls don't in order to offer the kernel-level protection and advanced security it does. ... The combination of this new, powerful technology, and a world where software can be written to various standards by so many different companies, unfortunately can result in compatibility issues such as these. Fortunately, the issues seem to hit a very small number of our users, but we are still taking the issues seriously and correcting things with other vendors as quickly as possible. Until fixes occur, a user can turn the OS firewall off or consider not running the conflicting product." 4. ZA, bundled with CA EZ Armor, rewrites HTML and truncates it at 256 KB. Berson: "Our privacy feature does modify HTML code in order to strip out advertisements and other unwanted content. This is a very simple and low-impact operation that, inasmuch as we've seen so far (in 3+ years of operation with no fundamental code changes), wouldn't have the effect this user is describing. If this customer writes to support, we can try and hone in on the problem." For my part, I'd like to emphasize that you should never have two real-time scanning operations — such as a software firewall, antivirus, or antispyware — running at the same time. Enable only one program in each category. It's fine to let two or more programs periodically scan your hard drive for spyware. But schedule each app to run its disk scan at a different time of the day. Berson encourages everyone who's having problems with ZoneAlarm to get help through the company's support page at ZoneLabs.com/tsform. But he went much farther than that. Berson invites any reader of the Windows Secrets Newsletter who doesn't get a solution from support to send e-mail to him personally at JBERSON AT ZONELABS DOT COM. Now that's what I call going the extra mile to help customers. Complete descriptions of the problems described above, including remarks about problems that were successfully resolved, are in the paid version of today's newsletter, below. There's no fixed fee to get the paid newsletter. You'll receive all new content for one year — and the ability to search all existing content — by making a voluntary financial contribution of any amount. How to upgrade To send us more information about Windows security software, or to send us a tip on any other subject, visit WindowsSecrets.com/contact. You'll receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of your choice if you send us a comment that we print. Brian Livingston is editor of the Windows Secrets Newsletter and the coauthor of Windows 2000 Secrets, Windows Me Secrets, and eight other books. ^ |
|
THE SECURITY BASELINE — the minimum you need for safe computing The Security Baseline as it now stands By Brian Livingston The new 6.0.667 release of the ZoneAlarm family of products hasn't completely eliminated every problem with the earlier "point-oh" version. The glitches that some users are reporting are covered as part of my top story, above. You should read that discussion in case any of it applies to you. Meanwhile, ZoneAlarm Security Suite 6 continues to enjoy Editors' Choice ratings from PC Magazine and CNET. In addition, a new PC World review finds that the new ZA suite removes far more active adware and spyware components than such competitors as Ad-Aware SE Personal and Spybot Search & Destroy. So ZA remains in the Security Baseline as the top-rated product in this category — until some other product surpasses it in test results. Based on the latest published tests, therefore, the best four products to give a PC comprehensive protection against hackers are (1) a Linksys hardware firewall, (2) ZoneAlarm Security Suite 6.0.667, (3) CounterSpy antispyware, and (4) an update-management tool of your choice. See details below.
|
|
FORWARDING INSTRUCTIONS — news gains value when it's shared Please share this information with your friends You're encouraged to refer your friends and colleagues to this free newsletter. Because most e-mail programs don't correctly display a formatted message that's been forwarded, simply call people's attention to the permanent Web address of this issue: WindowsSecrets.com/comp/050929. ^ |
|
WINDOWS GIZMOS — our product reviews of new stuff Devices help you connect, click, and swap
|
|
INDEX OF REVIEWS — our directory of product shootouts New digital cameras produce new reviews
|
|
HERE'S A TIP — you'll get a better newsletter if you choose the paid version You're reading the free version of the Windows Secrets Newsletter Subscribers to the paid version receive additional information in each issue. Some of the extras this week are: Paid subscribers can access all old and new paid newsletter content Make a contribution to support our research into Windows and you'll immediately be able to read and search through scores of valuable articles. In addition, paid subscribers are entitled to download valuable content that we license for you at least once every calendar quarter. To upgrade, simply make a contribution of any amount you choose If you do this by October 12, 2005, you'll instantly be sent the full, paid version of today's newsletter. To upgrade to the paid version of Windows Secrets, please visit WindowsSecrets.com/upgrade. Thanks in advance. ^ |
|
WACKY WEB WEEK — playing for you the Internet's greatest bits
USEFUL LINKS — more stuff that's good to know Inkjet wars: cheap ink vs. expensive The high cost of brand-name ink affects an ever-larger audience. Some people are doing something about the price of ink — but you need to know both the ups and the downs of the alternatives. (By Brian Livingston, Datamation) More info Inkjet wars 2: preserving your prints Using quality papers and inks, and storing documents in reasonably cool, dry, and dark places, can provide up to 100-year stability for documents and photos. (By Brian Livingston, Datamation) More info ^ ABOUT YOUR SUBSCRIPTION — we're here to serve you The Windows Secrets Newsletter (formerly Woody's Windows Watch and Brian's Buzz on Windows) is published twice a month, except for breaks in August and December. The newsletter is published on the Thursday after Microsoft Patch Tuesday (the 2nd Tuesday of each month) and two Thursdays after that. A short "newsletter update" is sometimes published between regular newsletters, if breaking news occurs. Publisher: WindowsSecrets.com LLC, 300 Queen Anne Ave. N. #456, Seattle, WA 98109 USA. Vendors, please send no unsolicited packages to this address (readers' letters are fine). Editor: Brian Livingston is the coauthor of Windows 2000 Secrets, Windows Me Secrets, and eight other books. Contributing Editors: Susan Bradley, Mark Burnett, Woody Leonhard, Chris Mosby. Research Director: Vickie Stevens. Program Director: Brent Scheffler. Trademarks: Windows is a registered trademark of Microsoft Corporation. The Windows Secrets series of books is published by Wiley Publishing Inc. The Windows Secrets Newsletter, WindowsSecrets.com, WinFind, Windows Gizmos, Index of Reviews, Briefing Session, Windows Patch Watch, Update Management, and Wacky Web Week are trademarks and service marks of WindowsSecrets.com LLC. All other marks are the trademarks or service marks of their respective owners. How to subscribe: Anyone may subscribe to this newsletter by visiting WindowsSecrets.com/info. Our Ironclad Privacy Guarantee: (1) We will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever; (2) We will never send you any unrequested e-mail, besides newsletter updates; and (3) All unsubscribe requests are always honored immediately, period. Privacy policy HOW TO UNSUBSCRIBE: To unsubscribe from the Windows Secrets Newsletter, Copyright © 2005 by WindowsSecrets.com LLC. All rights reserved. ^ |