U3 flash drives rendered useless on some PCs

Virginia culler By Virginia Culler

Readers are adding more weight to our less-than-glowing reviews of U3 flash software.

Many corporate IT administrators block U3 use completely, so if you use USB flash drives at work, you may want to avoid this platform.

Locked networks make U3 a bad fit

Associate editor Scott Dunn on Oct. 18 reviewed free, downloadable suites of “portable software” that you can run directly from flash drives. In a related, Oct. 11 review of flash drives themselves, he wrote, “Don’t base your drive choice on U3,” recommending non-U3 drives that are faster and have greater capacity at a lower price.

Insider tips, how-tos, best security practices, and more

Subscribe to Windows Secrets — free!

The Windows Secrets Newsletter brings you essential tricks for running Windows XP, Vista, 7, Internet Explorer, Firefox, Windows Update, and more — weekly, free.

My Windows 8 Consumer Preview: A Sneak Peek at the Windows 8 Public Beta

Bonus: get this free download when you subscribe
Interested in Windows 8 but don't know where to start? You have a friendly guide in My Windows 8 Consumer Preview: A Sneak Peek at the Windows 8 Public Beta, by Katherine Murray. This month, all subscribers can download Chapter 1 and Chapter 5. In this excerpt you will learn about the new look of Windows 8, how to make things happen in it, how to use the apps that come with it, and how to get more apps.

We guarantee your privacy: We will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever. We will never send you any unrequested e-mail. Unsubscribe requests are honored within one business day. Privacy Policy



Several readers wrote to inform us that, at their corporate workplaces, U3 drives are unworkable or banned due to certain behaviors in the software. Derek Douglas says:
  • “One drawback of U3 drives is that they try to install their software on the PC they’re connected to. Our company’s network is locked down to stop unauthorised software being installed onto PCs on the network. This therefore renders U3 drives useless and prevents you from displaying your big presentation, unless you saved a backup copy somewhere other than your U3 drive.”
While Scott’s article emphasized using flash drives on public computers rather than workplace ones, the U3 software-install behavior can still cause problems if you use a USB drive at an Internet café with similar security measures in place. Reader Ian Lucas writes to say, however, that he’s tested other portable apps on flash drives and they don’t present this problem.

If you do wish to use a U3 drive (or you’ve already bought one), reader Melvin Lewis suggests a free utility called Package Factory that can convert some regular programs to the .u3p format that’s used by U3 drives. The documentation for this utility gives the disclaimer that it works best with simple applications that don’t have many support files.

Comcast readers receive bounce notices

Most of our subscribers who use Comcast.net e-mail addresses saw bounce messages last week. Some users of this Internet service provider, however, received the newsletter with no problem. We’re working with Comcast and our e-mail broadcast service to prevent the ISP from bouncing our newsletters again.

In the meantime, please remember that you can always access the free version of the newsletter on the Web. Paid subscribers can read all paid content on our Web site by logging in with their e-mail address and reader number, which is shown at the top and bottom of every newsletter. We apologize for any inconvenience the Comcast bounces caused.

Readers Douglas, Lucas, and Lewis will each receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of their choice for sending tips we printed. Send us your tips via the Windows Secrets contact page.

The Known Issues column brings you readers’ comments on our recent articles. Virginia Culler is managing editor of WindowsSecrets.com.

Related posts:

  1. XP passwords rendered useless
  2. Securing USB flash drives
  3. Life Expectancy Of Flash Drives?
  4. Good deals on USB flash drives
  5. Free utility lets normal programs run on USB drives
= Paid content

All Windows Secrets articles posted on 2007-10-25: