Windows Secrets

Subscribers: Sign in

Enter your e-mail address to get a free subscription.
We guarantee your privacy
Skip to content
  • Home
  • Newsletter Archives
    • Current
    • LangaList Plus
    • Patch Watch
    • Wacky Web Week
    • Security Baseline
  • E-Books
  • Lounge
  • About us
    • Refunds
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertise
  • Contact
  • Your Account
    • Upgrade
    • Preferences
    • Bonus Download
    • Unsubscribe
Home>Microsoft charges customers for free services

Windows Secrets Newsletter • Issue 135 • 2008-01-03 • Circulation: over 400,000


Table of contents 
  • Top Story: Microsoft charges customers for free services
  • Known Issues: VoIP alternatives trim long-distance bills
  • Wacky Web Week: Time for your New Year’s resolution, baby!
  • Woody's Windows: How to undelete pictures on your camera
  • Perimeter Scan: More and better uses for Process Explorer

 
Top Story

Microsoft charges customers for free services

Scott dunn By Scott Dunn

Thousands of customers are paying almost $120 USD per year to Microsoft for an Internet subscription service that includes e-mail, security, and other features.

But Microsoft gives away almost identical services absolutely free in Windows Live and the Windows operating system itself, while neglecting to inform those who pay through the nose.

Free Windows Live eclipses MSN Premium

Microsoft’s for-pay service, known as MSN Premium, is a collection of broadband features that must be accessed through a special browser: MSN Explorer. Once downloaded and installed, this browser supports Web surfing, an interface for e-mail and calendar programs, and Microsoft’s online encyclopedia, Encarta Premium. Other features, such as an included digital image editor, are accessible by launching a separate application.

MSN Premium is typically marketed by Internet service providers who are Microsoft’s partners, such as Qwest and Verizon in the U.S. and Bell Sympatico in Canada. (Qwest currently offers Windows Live instead of MSN.) Consumers can also purchase MSN Premium directly from Microsoft Online Services. The current version, according to the Microsoft site, is MSN Premium 9.5, which costs $9.95 per month in the United States.

According to page 11 of a PDF file on the Bell Sympatico site, more than 8.2 million people worldwide subscribe to MSN Premium. Microsoft does not release figures on how many of these users pay the monthly fee, and how many receive MSN Premium as part of a bundle from their ISPs.

The subscription service was first launched for broadband customers in 2004. Since then, however, Microsoft has released a new collection of Web services under the Windows Live brand, new versions of Internet Explorer, and service packs for Windows XP — all free — that duplicate the features that MSN Premium customers pay precious money for each month.

Microsoft’s FAQ page promotes MSN Premium as having 21 features. Yet nearly every one of the features is available from Microsoft for free — either through Windows Live or existing versions of Windows and Internet Explorer.

Table 1 lists these services and more, showing exactly where consumers who’ve been sold MSN Premium could obtain the same or comparable services from Microsoft for free.

Table 1. Nearly every MSN Premium feature is free in Windows Live or in Windows itself.

MSN Premium
($10/mo USD)

Windows Live
(free)

Included in Windows
(or free from Microsoft)

Parental controls
Windows Live Family Safety
Parental controls included in Vista
Phishing filter
Included in Live Hotmail
Included in IE 7
Outlook Connector
Includes Outlook Connector
Free download
Digital Image Standard 2006 Editor and Digital Image Standard Library
Windows Live Photo Gallery
Windows Photo Gallery included in Vista
MSN Mail
Windows Live Hotmail
 
Virus Guard from McAfee
Live OneCare scan
 
E-mail virus protection
Included in Live Hotmail
 
10 GB of mail storage
5 GB of mail storage
 
Junk e-mail guard
Included in Live Hotmail
 
Up to 10 additional member accounts
Create unlimited linked Live IDs
 
Multiple e-mail account support
Add multiple existing mail accounts in desktop version
 
Anytime, anywhere access to e-mail
Mail available from any browser, plus Mobile Mail for cell phone
 
Designer e-mail with photo albums
Included in desktop version of Live Hotmail
 
Alert reminders
Windows Live Alerts
 
Calendar
Calendar included in Live Hotmail, Windows Live Calendar Beta
 
Encarta Premium
Windows Live Academic Search Beta
 
Virtual Earth
Live maps
 
TrueSwitch for transferring info from other e-mail accounts
Included in Live Hotmail
 
Free technical support
Windows Live Support
 
Firewall Included in XP SP2 and Vista
Webroot Spy Sweeper for MSN
 
Windows Defender is a free download for XP, included in Vista
Pop-up guard
 
Included in IE 6 and 7
Photo Story Lite
 
Photo Story 3 is a free download; Windows Movie Maker is included in XP, Vista
Messenger photo swap
 
Sending photos is part of Windows Messenger, included in XP; free download for Vista
Member center
 
Multiple Microsoft communities
Download manager
—
—


About the only MSN Premium feature that Microsoft doesn’t offer for free in some other form is the MSN download manager. But consumers can easily visit a site like Snapfiles, which lists several third-party equivalents at absolutely no cost.

Microsoft is running a similar “pay for what’s free” scheme in its Hotmail Plus service. According to Microsoft’s promotional page, Microsoft sells subscriptions to Hotmail Plus for $20 a year, promising junk e-mail filters and the ability to access e-mail via Microsoft Outlook. Similar features that are almost as generous are totally free in Microsoft’s Windows Live service.

To give credit where it’s due, Hotmail Plus does give its paying users more storage space (2GB), larger attachments (up to 20MB per message), and the elimination of ads, compared with the free version of Hotmail. MSN Premium, however, has few such advantages over the free services that paying subscribers never hear about from Microsoft.

Why is Microsoft competing with itself?

It’s not all that surprising to find a software company offering a free equivalent to a competitor’s commercial product. But Windows Live and MSN Premium are produced by the same company. What’s going on?

Although not addressing MSN Premium per se, Microsoft has repeatedly asserted, such as in press releases on Sept. 11, 2006, and May 6, 2007, that “MSN and Windows Live will be offered alongside each other as complementary services.”

Echoing this position, Windows Live general manager Brian Hall told a reporter at the ReadWriteWeb blog in June 2007 that the distinction between MSN and Live will become more apparent as Windows Live evolves.

Such fine points of product positioning may be lost on MSN Premium customers, who have a right to wonder why they’re paying for services that the same company offers for free.

In May 2007, as described in a Microsoft statement, the Redmond company forcibly migrated all MSN Hotmail customers to the newer Windows Live Hotmail. This would have been the ideal time for the company to inform MSN Premium’s paying customers that Microsoft was offering basically the same service for free.

To my knowledge, no such announcement has ever been made. On the contrary, when I recently signed up to pay $10 a month for MSN Premium as a test, I received no alerts or e-mails informing me that a newer, no-cost option was available.

Whether MSN Premium will eventually provide services superior to Windows Live only time will tell. At the moment, MSN Premium customers have every right to consider themselves cheated.

Have a tip about Windows? Readers receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of their choice for sending tips we print. Send us your tips via the Windows Secrets contact page.

Scott Dunn is associate editor of the Windows Secrets Newsletter. He has been a contributing editor of PC World since 1992 and currently writes for the magazine’s Here’s How section.

 
Known Issues

VoIP alternatives trim long-distance bills

By Scott Dunn

Our Dec. 13, 2007, issue explained how a VoIP device called MagicJack, which charges only $20 USD per year for unlimited calls from anywhere in the world to U.S. and Canada phones, might make big long-distance bills a thing of the past.

As a result, many of our readers pointed out other innovative Internet products and services to help cut your phone bill down to size.

Numerous readers wrote in to make us aware of their own preferred Voice over Internet Protocol systems for lowering their phone bills. We haven’t tested all of the following services or products, so do your homework before diving in:

• Jajah. John Cossins and many others wrote to tell us how pleased they were with the service offered by Jajah. Unlike many VoIP services, Jajah doesn’t require any installable software or hardware (other than an ordinary telephone). You go to the Web site and enter your phone number and the number you wish to call. Jajah does the rest by calling you and then connecting you with your party. Jajah also offers a service called Jajah Direct, which doesn’t even require an Internet connection. You simply call a local phone number and provide the destination number. Readers report good voice quality and low per-minute rates, starting at 2.9 cents per minute, which are listed at the Jajah site. Calls between any two Jajah customers are free.

• Vyke and VoipCheap. Reader Alf Manders wrote to tell us about Vyke, and Leon Fiss wanted to inform us of VoipCheap. Both services are similar to Skype in that they require you to download and install software. You’ll need a microphone and speakers on your computer if you don’t have a headset.

• ChatterBug. Kurt Kincel prefers the ChatterBug hardware device, which requires no computer or Internet connection. You simply connect the $25 USD device between your phone and wall jack and pay $10 a month for long-distance calls. WSN editorial director Brian Livingston reviewed the ChatterBug in a Feb. 21, 2006, Executive Tech column.

• GrandCentral. A reader named Roger is excited about the features offered by GrandCentral, a service that was recently acquired by Google. Unlike the other VoIP services mentioned above, GrandCentral is not designed to lower your long distance bills. Instead, it aims to unite all your phones under a single number that GrandCentral provides. Incoming calls are routed to your other numbers or to your voice mail. The service can also unite all your voice mails in one place, which you can manage from the Web site. You can screen calls, block unwanted calls, dial from an online address book, record and play back calls, and more. The service is currently free.

• Skype. Finally, a few readers had comments on Skype-related hardware. Richard Sale is pleased with uConnect, a $60 USB device that lets you make Skype or landline calls from an analog phone that you plug into the device. Dave Eisenbraun recommends the Philips VOIP841, a $130 list ($110 street) cordless hybrid Skype and landline phone, which eliminates the need for a computer. Leon Sizemore and others wrote to point out that Skype does not require a special headset if your computer has speakers and a mic.

MagicJack may not work on restricted systems

Regarding the Dec. 13, 2007, article, reader Paul Wrenn asks about my statement that MagicJack installs no software on the host computer. Paul cites an eWeek article stating that the MagicJack software “does not run directly from the device,” but “fully installs on the Windows system.”

To test this, I used the freeware product TinyWatcher to scan a Windows XP system before and connecting MagicJack. The TinyWatcher scan indicated that, contrary to prior statements by a MagicJack representative, MagicJack does add two files to the Windows System32 folder (usbaudio.sys and utscsci.exe). It also adds four entries to the Windows Registry.

Although these changes are minimal compared to some other VoIP programs, they nevertheless suggest that MagicJack may not work on a computer whose policies prohibit any software installation.

Patch resolves ADS issue on Windows Home Server

Our Dec. 6 issue described how to make files invisible to Windows Explorer and most other Windows tools by using alternate data streams (ADS), a feature of Microsoft’s NTFS file system. Our Known Issues column on Dec. 13 then pointed out that alternate data streams in an NTFS file can be corrupted if the file is copied to a shared folder on a system running Windows Home Server (WHS). Microsoft Knowledge Base article 943393 acknowledges the bug.

Computer engineer and system builder Philip Churchill writes with the good news that a patch is available for WHS:
  • “Just to let you know that the November 2007 update for WHS resolved this problem, as can be viewed in KB article 941914. The title is misleading, as it [the update] corrects seven problems with WHS, including the ADS problem. More info is also available at my blog.”
Thanks, Philip! KB article 943393 was edited by Microsoft on Dec. 28 to recommend the WHS update as a solution to the problem.

According to Philip’s blog entry, the fix was made available through Windows’ routine Automatic Updates process, so your WHS systems may have already been patched.

Readers Cossins, Manders, Fiss, Kincel, Roger, Sale, Eisenbraun, Sizemore, Wrenn, and Churchill will each receive a gift certificate for a book, CD, or DVD of their choice for sending tips we printed. Send us your tips via the Windows Secrets contact page.


 
Wacky Web Week

Time for your New Year’s resolution, baby!

New year resolution  We all hate them, and yet we all make them. Inevitably, however, we all break them. Fitness always seems to be on the top of everyone’s resolutions for the New Year. Unfortunately for the little baby in this video, it hasn’t quite made it to the top of his father’s list.

This funny, 20-second video clip for a fitness club shows just one reason why exercise should be taken seriously. It’s for the children! Play the video


 
Woody's Windows

How to undelete pictures on your camera

Woody leonhard By Woody Leonhard

Every year about this time, my inbox overflows with anguished hollers for holiday help.

“My brother-in-law [or some other equally nefarious scoundrel] deleted all the pics on my new camera,” the tale of woe goes, “how do I get ‘em back?”


First, shutterbug, do no harm

Start by peeling yourself off the ceiling and unwinding that strand of garland you surreptitiously slipped around your brother-in-law’s neck.

As long as you haven’t used the camera after the pictures were deleted, there’s a very good chance that you can get them all back. Likely as not, it won’t cost a cent. It’ll take a little time, but disposing of your brother-in-law would probably take longer.

If you’ve deleted a picture or a bunch of pictures on your camera — whether by injudiciously hitting the “delete” key on the camera itself, by copying the pics to your PC and having the PC delete them as they were copied, or by any of a zillion other bonehead methods — you must start by doing nothing.

Don’t take any more pictures with the camera. Don’t try to use the camera’s built-in menu. Don’t reformat the hard drive. Just sit and chill while you figure out what to do next.

What really happens when you delete pics

When you delete a picture on a camera, you don’t actually delete the picture.

This article is part of our paid content. Subscribe.

Already a paid subscriber? Click here to login.


 
Perimeter Scan

More and better uses for Process Explorer

Ryan russell By Ryan Russell

In my Dec. 6 column, I introduced Microsoft’s free Process Explorer and some of its basic functions that enable you to understand what’s running on your PC.

Today, I’ll walk you through using PE to accomplish some specific tasks, so fire up your copy and follow along.


How to find resource hogs on your PC

If you want to make frequent use of PE, one of the first things you’ll want to do is customize the set of columns that it shows. This will give you all the information you want at a glance. In the following example, we’re going to check for processes that are using too many resources.

In PE, click on the View menu, and select Select columns. This will give you a Select Columns window. Click on the Process Performance tab. Make sure Threads and Handle Count are checked. Go to the Process Memory tab, and make sure Virtual Size, Working Set Size, Peak Working Set Size, GDI Objects, and USER Objects are checked.

This will cause columns for each of these items to appear in the main PE window. You can sort by any one of these columns by clicking on the column name for that column.

In my experience (heavily influenced by my working in a software quality-assurance function for several years), there are three main groups of resources a Windows process can go overboard with: (1) CPU, (2) memory, and (3) handles and objects.

This article is part of our paid content. Subscribe.

Already a paid subscriber? Click here to login.


YOUR SUBSCRIPTION

The Windows Secrets Newsletter is published weekly on the 1st through 4th Thursdays of each month, plus occasional news updates. We skip an issue on the 5th Thursday of any month, the week of Thanksgiving, and the last two weeks of August and December. Windows Secrets is a continuation of four merged publications: Brian's Buzz on Windows and Woody's Windows Watch in 2004, the LangaList in 2006, and the Support Alert Newsletter in 2008.

Publisher: WindowsSecrets.com, 1218 Third Ave., Suite 1515, Seattle, WA 98101 USA. Vendors, please send no unsolicited packages to this address (readers' letters are fine).

Editor in chief: Tracey Capen. Senior editors: Fred Langa, Woody Leonhard. Copyeditor: Roberta Scholz. Program director: Tony Johnston. Contributing editors: Yardena Arar, Susan Bradley, Scott Dunn, Michael Lasky, Scott Mace, Ryan Russell, Lincoln Spector, Robert Vamosi, Becky Waring. Product manager: Andy Boyd. Advertising director: Eric Gilley.

Trademarks: Microsoft and Windows are registered trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. The Windows Secrets series of books is published by Wiley Publishing Inc. The Windows Secrets Newsletter, WindowsSecrets.com, Support Alert, LangaList, LangaList Plus, WinFind, Security Baseline, Patch Watch, Perimeter Scan, Wacky Web Week, the Logo Design (W, S or road, and Star), and the slogan Everything Microsoft Forgot to Mention all are trademarks and service marks of WindowsSecrets.com. All other marks are the trademarks or service marks of their respective owners.

HOW TO SUBSCRIBE: Anyone may subscribe to this newsletter by visiting our free signup page.

WE GUARANTEE YOUR PRIVACY:

1. We will never sell, rent, or give away your address to any outside party, ever.
2. We will never send you any unrequested e-mail, besides newsletter updates.
3. All unsubscribe requests are honored immediately, period.  Privacy policy

HOW TO UNSUBSCRIBE: To unsubscribe from the Windows Secrets Newsletter,
  • Visit our Unsubscribe page.
Copyright © 2012 by WindowsSecrets.com. All rights reserved.

Table of contents

Top-scoring articles in the past 12 months
  • Leaving long cookie trails throughout the Web 5.00
  • Windows-like security for Android devices 5.00
  • Win7′s no-reformat, nondestructive reinstall 4.53
  • The sorry tale of the (un)Secure Sockets Layer 4.42
  • RPV: Win7′s least-known data-protection system 4.33
  • Recovery: the last step in total data security 4.30
  • Time for a .NET update we can’t ignore 4.30
  • Getting the most from Windows Search — Part 1 4.25
  • Revising printing habits saves money and trees 4.25
  • Upgrades end in erratic, partial hangs 4.25
  • Pros and cons of a ‘keyfile’ password 4.21
  • Beating back Duku and a plethora of other threats 4.20
  • Office 2007 gets its final service pack 4.19
  • Putting Registry-/system-cleanup apps to the test 4.19
  • One year and 99 security bulletins later 4.18
  • 1.8TB external drive goes down hard 4.17
  • Don’t pay for software you don’t need — Part 3 4.16
  • Internet Explorer gets another round of patches 4.15
  • Is your free AV tool a ‘resource pig?’ 4.15
  • Vacation’s over; it’s a big round of patches 4.15
  • Remote access leads to remote attacks 4.15
  • Keeping you up to date: say no to .NET — again 4.14
  • Take control of Google’s privacy policy settings 4.14
  • Office File Validation patch leads to problems 4.14
  • The advanced system-recover toolkit 4.13
  • New “419″ scam involves PayPal and Western Union 4.12
  • Readers’ best personal-privacy tips 4.11
  • Getting the most from Windows Search — Part 2 4.11
  • Re-examining Dropbox and its alternatives 4.10
  • Easily edit Windows’ right-click context menus 4.09
Connect with us Follow us on Twitter Connect with us on Facebook View our RSS Feeds
  • Home|
  • Newsletter|
  • About Windows Secrets|
  • Advertise with us|
  • Unsubscribe|
  • Sitemap|
  • Affiliates|
Trademarks: Microsoft and Windows are registered trademarks of Microsoft Corporation. The Windows Secrets series of books is published by Wiley Publishing Inc. The Windows Secrets Newsletter, WindowsSecrets.com, WinFind, Windows Gizmos, Security Baseline, Patch Watch, Perimeter Scan, Wacky Web Week, the Logo Design (W, S or road, and Star), and the slogan Everything Microsoft Forgot to Mention all are trademarks and service marks of iNET Interactive. All other marks are the trademarks or service marks of their respective owners.
iNET Interactive Copyright © 2011 iNET Interactive.
All rights reserved.
Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy
Internet Services
  • Web Hosting Talk
  • HostingCon
  • Hosting Catalog
  • Host Voice
Web Development
  • Hot Scripts
  • DB Forums
Digital Marketing
  • ABestWeb
  • Search Marketing Standard
  • PayPerClickUniverse
  • SEMCompare
Consumer Tech
  • Windows Secrets
  • Overclockers
  • Mac Forums

Learn more about
advertising opportunities across the iNET Interactive Network.

LiquidWeb